Just because someone is deaf doesn't mean they're stupid, and that's how people treated Esther. She could see them roll their eyes and she could sense their irritation when she asked them to repeat themselves. Esther had suffered a severe hearing loss due to illness as a child. All Esther wanted was to be treated as a normal twenty-five-year-old woman. She lived life as a recluse and attended very few Amish gatherings. When a storm damages Esther's house, she is forced to spend time with Amish builder, Devon Hershberger. Devon and Esther quickly become friends and Esther hopes their...

Florence Lapp's house has burned down, and her gun is missing. She learns that Dustin, a young man she knows, has been accused of murder and her gun has been found in his car. Small things don't add up, and Florence believes the young man is innocent. Suspecting that her young friend has been framed, she turns to her sisters, Ettie and Elsa-May, for help. Spurred on by the announcement that Florence is staying at their house until the case is solved, Ettie and Elsa-May hurry to find the truth. Dustin says that he had no knowledge of a gun and didn't know the murdered girl. Ettie begins to...

Amish man, Thomas Strongberg, had fallen off a ladder and is found on the floor of the family barn. After another man is found dead in the same barn, the police begin investigating Thomas' death as a murder rather than an accident. Thea Hersh was there on the day Thomas died and heard him have a disagreement with an Englisher. When Thea enlists the help of her friend, Austin, to investigate Thomas's death, they are arrested and thrown in jail. From her prison cell, Thea refuses to talk to anyone, but Ettie Smith. Can Ettie discover the mystery of the strange lights in the Strongberg barn at...

Widowed and pregnant Amish woman, Sarah Kurtz, is in dire financial circumstances. Relief comes unexpectedly when her late uncle leaves her his income-producing farm in Sugarcreek. After Sarah's baby is born, she leaves Lancaster County and moves to her new home, unaware there is a long-term tenant living in the adjoining grossdaddi haus. When she meets her disagreeable neighbor, Joshua Byler, her irritation with him is softened by his two children. Not wanting her daughter to be raised with one parent and no siblings as she was, Sarah knows the only solution is to marry again. With Christmas...

Elderly Amish widows, Ettie and her sister, Elsa-May, settle down for a comfortable Christmas night not knowing they're in for a surprise. One by one guests arrive claiming they've been invited to a 'Christmas dinner they'll never forget.' Among the guests are Ettie's estranged daughter, Myra, and the retired Detective Crowley. When a man is found dead in the widows' front yard, Crowley immediately takes over and determines that the man has been murdered. Myra recognizes the dead man as her enemy, Earl Fuller. Crowley soon learns that two more people in the house wanted Earl out of the way....