She stared down the barrel of her first husband's shotgun. She bore the pain and uncertainty of her second husband's affair. For Sue Andrews, love was always a dangerous game, physically and emotionally taxing-and destined to end in heartbreak.

But when a friend compared her plight to the book When Bad Things Happen to Good People, Andrews became determined: she would stop being a victim and take control of her life once and for all.

So after two marriages, two divorces, and moving from Illinois to Michigan to Georgia to Florida, she finally found herself back where...