Annie Benson, widowed and seven months pregnant with twins, is convinced God doesn't waste time on unimportant people like her. She's working as a waitress in a little California town when she receives word she's inherited a small ranch in Wyoming. Excited and relieved, Annie wants to spend Christmas in her new home. As she exits the bus, a very handsome man offers her a hand. He is the local doctor and her new neighbor, Gabriel St. Nick. While stuck in a snowstorm and in labor, can Gabe convince Annie that God loves her and so does he?

Grace Stoltzfus has loved Jacob Yoder since she was a child. When she meets an Englisher at the market place she is torn. When she sees Jacob with another young woman, she leaves her Amish community and marries the young Englisher who is soon deployed to Afghanistan. Once she's alone Grace realizes she's still in love with Jacob. She becomes a widow and finds out she's pregnant on the same day. Grace returns home scared and alone. Will her family and community forgive her and allow her to stay, or send her away to raise her baby alone?

Katie Nelson testifies against her abusive step-father for driving drunk, which caused the accident that killed her mother. After she testifies against him, she starts receiving threats against her and her little brother, Nicky. Katie takes Nicky and flies to Flat Creek, Missouri to stay with her friend Jessica, where she meets Jessica's brother-in-law, Jordan Kensington. Can Jordan and his family keep Katie and Nicky safe? Or has she placed them all in danger?