Lily is in the hospital, Todd won't stop asking if she's had sex with the new guy, and speaking of the new guy--he may have just eaten her ex. That was one hell of a night. Except technically, the night isn't over yet. Only two hours have passed since the events of 'My Boyfriend is a Monster' have taken place and Nathan needs his brother Louis' help to deal with a big problem--namely, trying to dispose of a body in Chicago. Nathan's other siblings are investigating some strange occurrences that might be related to the monstrous murders taking place in the city--with a little help from Mommy...