Abigail Forrestor is a widow with two children, twins Chloe and Cole. She owns a bookstore in a small town amid the Amish Community. After her daughtrer befriends a young Amish girl, an ex-Amish man comes into the store claiming to be her uncle. Levi Bontregger left the Community after he argued against the very beliefs he had grown up with. As the relationship between Abby and Levi grows, something keeps them fighting for protection and battling their faith. When Levi overhears a conversation between two criminals, he immediately goes to the authorities but these men find out and from then...