A thoughtful and comprehensive weighing up of all the arguments presented by his friend Solomon in favor of Antonie Brentano, followed by a detailed presentation of and then a synoptic comparison with the evidence supporting Josephine Brunsvik. The latter the clear winner. Harry Goldschmidt, Beethoven scholar of international repute, made the hunt for the Immortal Beloved to the focus of an unorthodox and precisely drawn Beethoven portrait. His sovereign style is based on many years of meticulous research. With annotations and amendments by translator John E Klapproth