Elsie Miller is secretly engaged. Without warning, she's uprooted from her home to travel to Hollybrook to care for her injured grandmother. While there, she is confronted by her past love, Matthew, the boy who rejected her in her youth. Emotions are sparked, and Elsie realizes she's still in love with him. But how can she possibly feel like this? She is engaged, and Matthew is courting someone else... Becca Warren escapes her abusive husband and finds herself in Amish country. She is discovered by Elsie, who risks everything to help her. How can Elsie's calm life have suddenly become plagued...