Ever since witnessing an avalanche devour his parents at age twelve, Michael DiBianco has had an odd obsession with the divine. Today, a renowned physicist, Harvard Divinity professor, and bestselling author of The Newton Theories and The Book, DiBianco has devoted his life to uncovering the secrets of the Bible.

A prophetic collection of Newton papers have been stolen from a library in Jerusalem. DiBianco is escorted from his classroom and questioned by the FBI. He's shown a fistful of Polaroids displaying several assassinations along with several unclear xeroxes of mysterious...