Authority and Expertise in Ancient Scientific Culture

ISBN-13: 9781107629646 / Angielski / Miękka / 2021 / 485 str.

Scotland) Jason König (University of St Andrews;Greg Woolf

Opis

How did ancient scientific and knowledge-ordering writers make their work authoritative? This book answers that question for a wide range of ancient disciplines, from mathematics, medicine, architecture and agriculture, through to law, historiography and philosophy - focusing mainly, but not exclusively, on the literature of the Roman Empire. It draws attention to habits that these different fields had in common, while also showing how individual texts and authors manipulated standard techniques of self-authorisation in distinctive ways. It stresses the importance of competitive and assertive styles of self-presentation, and also examines some of the pressures that pulled in the opposite direction by looking at authors who chose to acknowledge the limitations of their own knowledge or resisted close identification with narrow versions of expert identity. A final chapter by Sir Geoffrey Lloyd offers a comparative account of scientific authority and expertise in ancient Chinese, Indian and Mesopotamian culture.

Recenzje

'… anyone interested in the study of scientific/technical literature will certainly find something useful in one or another of the seventeen individual papers. … the copyediting is excellent and the volume is easy to use: it has copious notes and bibliography (860 titles); the original texts are often given in addition to the English translation; and there is a helpful index.' Emilie-Jade Poliquin, Bryn Mawr Classical Review

Spis treści

1. Introduction: self-assertion and its alternatives in ancient scientific and technical writing Jason König; 2. Philosophical authority in the Imperial period Michael Trapp; 3. Philosophical authority in the Younger Seneca Harry Hine; 4. Iurisperiti: 'men skilled in law' Jill Harries; 5. Making and defending claims to authority in Vitruvius' De architectura Daniel Harris-McCoy; 6. Fragile expertise and the authority of the past: the 'Roman art of war' Marco Formisano; 7. Conflicting models of authority and expertise in Frontinus' Strategemata Alice König; 8. The authority of writing in Varro's De re rustica Aude Doody; 9. The limits of enquiry in Imperial Greek didactic poetry Emily Kneebone; 10. Expertise, 'character', and the 'authority effect' in the Early Roman History of Dionysius of Halicarnassus Nicolas Wiater; 11. The authority of Galen's witnesses Daryn Lehoux; 12. Anatomy and aporia in Galen's On the Construction of Fetuses Ralph M. Rosen; 13. Varro the Roman Cynic: the destruction of religious authority in the Antiquitates Rerum Divinarum Leah Kronenberg; 14. Signs, seers and senators: divinatory expertise in Cicero and Nigidius Figulus Katharina Volk; 15. The public face of expertise: utility, zeal, and collaboration in Ptolemy's Syntaxis Johannes Wietzke; 16. The authority of mathematical expertise and the question of ancient writing more geometrico Reviel Netz; 17. Authority and expertise: some cross-cultural comparisons G. E. R. Lloyd.