Śabdapramāṇa: Word and Knowledge: A Doctrine in Mīmāṃsā-Nyāya Philosophy (with Reference to Advaita Vedā

ISBN-13: 9789401078108 / Angielski / Miękka / 2011 / 384 str.

P. P. Bilimoria

Opis

Dr PurusQttama Bilimoria's book on sabdapramaIJa is an important one, and so is likely to arouse much controversy. I am pleased to be able to write a Foreword to this book, at a stage in my philosophical thinking when my own interests have been turning towards the thesis of sabdapramaIJa as the basis of Hindu religious and philosophical tradition. Dr Bilimoria offers many novel interpretations of classical Hindu theories about language, meaning, understanding and knowing. These interpretations draw upon the conceptual resources of contemporary analytic and phenomenological philosophies, without sacrificing the authentIcity that can arise only out of philologically grounded scholarship. He raises many issues, and claims to have resolved some of them. Certainly, he advances the overall discussion, and this is the best one could hope for in writing on a topic to which the best minds of antiquity and modern times have applied themselves. In this Foreword, I wish to focus on one of the issues which I have raised on earlier occasions, and on which Dr Bilimoria has several important things to say. The issue is: is sabdabodha eo ipso a linguistic knowing, i. e. , sabdapramll, or does Sabdabodha amount to knowing only when certain specifiable conditions are satisfied. It the second alternative be accepted, these additional conditions could not be the same as the familiar Ilsatti (contiguity), yogyata (semantic fitness), dka;,k~ll (expectancy) and tlltparya (intention), for these are, on the theory, conditions of sabdabodha itself.

Spis treści

The problem.- The approach.- Aim and objectives.- The thesis and its background.- —pram??a.- —j??na.- —pram?.- —sábda.- Ideality of language.- ?ruti.- The ‘dogma’ of sruti: apauru?eya.- The text and its author.- Cit: consciousness in the knowing process.- Dharmar?ja and Navya-ny?ya.- 1. Outline of the Argument for ?abdapramÅ?a.- 2. On Words.- Linguistic kara?a and the word.- A. Kara?a, causal instrument for ??bdabodha.- B. What is a word?.- 3. On Meaning.- A. Some general remarks on ‘meaning’.- B. Indian theories of ‘meaning’.- C. The linguistic functions of ‘meaning’.- 4. ??bdabodha: Psycholinguistics of Sentence Understanding.- A. ??bdabodha.- B. Sa?sargamary?d?.- 5. The K?ra?s.- A. Ák??k?? — syntactic expectancy.- B. ?satti — linguistic contiguity.- 6. The Phenomenological K?ranas.- A. Yogyat? — semantic competency.- B. T?tparya — intentionality.- 7. ?abdapr?m?nya — Problem of Truth and Authority of the Word.- A. Truth and falsity of ??bdabodha.- B. ‘Authority and Praxis’ —?ptabh?va.- Appendixes.- B. Bibliography.- A. Primary sources.- B. Secondary sources and related texts.- Indexes.- Name index.- General index.