Revolution in Russia: Reassessments of 1917

ISBN-13: 9780521405850 / Angielski / Miękka / 1992 / 456 str.

Edith R. Frankel; Baruch Knei-Paz; Jonathan Frankel

Opis

The Russian Revolution of 1917 continues to be a subject of most intense controversy; and the fundamental questions which have divided observers over the last seventy years still stir fierce debate. In this volume, eighteen leading specialists from different generations, countries and schools of thought, re-examine the key issues and events of that crucial year. Some of the articles examine the unfolding crisis 'from below', describing developments in specific localities or organisations: others put the emphasis on the view as seen 'from above', on Lenin as leader of the Bolshevik party and of the emergent Soviet states. Other contributors explore the roles played by the officer corps, the industrialists, the peasants, the factory workers and the Soviets as well as the part of the Press and the different nationalities. Never before has so comprehensive a selection of original essays on 1917, written in the West, been collected in one volume.

Recenzje

"Revolution in Russia, edited by three Israeli historians, which grew out of a conference in honor of Israel Getzler in 1988, is an important contribution to this debate, and it is a tribute to Getzler that there are a number of high-quality articles that represent a timely state of the art on Western historiography on the October Revolution....Revolution in Russia is an important volume that should be widely read. It addresses itself to the issues, problems, limitations and the future agenda in the historiography of the Russian Revolution." Tsuyoshi Hasegawa, Russian Review

Spis treści

Preface; Introduction: 1917: Revolution and historical alternatives Jonathan Frankel; Part I. Political Power and Mass Action: 1. Soviets as agents of democratization Israel Getzler; 2. Political power in the Russian Revolution: a case study of Saratov Donald J. Raleigh; 3. The Red Guards, spontaneity, and the October Revolution Rex A. Wade; 4. Officers of the General Staff and the Kornilov Movement Allan Wildman; Part II. Peasants, Workers and Bourgoisie: 5. The peasantry in the Revolution of 1917 John Channon; 6. Perceptions and realities of labor protest, March to October 1917 Diane Koenker and William Rosenberg; 7. October in the Ivanovo-Kineshma industrial region David Mandel; 8. Commercial-industrial circles in revolution: the failure of 'industrial progressivism' Ziva Galiliy Garcia; Part III. Nationalities: 9. Nationalism and class as factors in the Revolution of 1917 Ronald G. Suny; 10. Georgian social democracy in 1917 Stephen F. Jones; 11. The ethnic Germans in the Russian Revolution Ingeborg Fleischhauer; Part IV. Leninism and the Making of October: 12. Lenin, socialism and the state in 1917 Neil Harding; 13. Bolsheviks on political campaign in 1917: a case study of the war question Robert Service; 14. Lenin's time budget: the Smolny period John Keep; Part V. 1917 in Retrospect: Historiography and Theory: 15. Problem of spontaneity and leadership in the Russian Revolution of February 1917 D. A. Longley; 16. The libertarians vindicated? the libertarian view of the Revolution in the light of recent western research Edward Acton; 17. Russian Marxism: theory, action and outcome Baruch Knei-Paz.