Proof Theory: The First Step Into Impredicativity

ISBN-13: 9783540693185 / Angielski / Miękka / 2008 / 390 str.

Wolfram Pohlers

Opis

The kernel of this book consists of a series of lectures on in?nitary proof theory which I gave during my time at the Westfalische ] Wilhelms-Universitat ] in Munster ] . It was planned as a successor of Springer Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1407. H- ever, when preparing it, I decided to also include material which has not been treated in SLN 1407. Since the appearance of SLN 1407 many innovations in the area of - dinal analysis have taken place. Just to mention those of them which are addressed in this book: Buchholz simpli?ed local predicativity by the invention of operator controlled derivations (cf. Chapter 9, Chapter 11); Weiermann detected applications of methods of impredicative proof theory to the characterization of the provable recursive functions of predicative theories (cf. Chapter 10); Beckmann improved Gentzen's boundedness theorem (which appears as Stage Theorem (Theorem 6. 6. 1) in this book) to Theorem 6. 6. 9, a theorem which is very satisfying in itself - though its real importance lies in the ordinal analysis of systems, weaker than those treated here. Besides these innovations I also decided to include the analysis of the theory (? -REF) as an example of a subtheory of set theory whose ordinal analysis only 2 0 requires a ?rst step into impredicativity. The ordinal analysis of(? -FXP) of non- 0 1 0 monotone? -de?nable inductive de?nitions in Chapter 13 is an application of the 1 analysis of(? -REF).

Recenzje

From the reviews:

"Proof Theory takes various axiom systems ... that treat induction in different ways and analyzes them from the ordinal viewpoint to gauge their relative strengths. ... This new version includes several developments in the field that have occurred over the twenty years since the original. Although the current book, appearing in the Universitext series, claims to be 'pitched at undergraduate/graduate level,' an undergraduate course out of Proof theory would be ambitious indeed." (Leon Harkleroad, The Mathematical Association of America, March, 2009)

"The book is addressed primarily to students of mathematical logic interested in the basics of proof theory, and it can be used both for introductory and advanced courses in proof theory. ... this book may be recommended to a larger circle of readers interested in proof theory." (Branislav Boricic, Zentrablatt MATH, Vol. 1153, 2009)

"This is a textbook-an excellent one-on proof theory, starting from the very elementary (heuristic accounts of sets, ordinals, logic, etc.), and going into a sophisticated area (impredicativity). ... The author's main tool is enquiry into truth complexity and ordinal analysis." (M. Yasuhara, Mathematical Reviews, Issue 2010 a)

Spis treści

1 Historical Background.- 2 Primitive Recursive Functions and Relations.- 2.1 Primitive Recursive Functions.- 2.2 Primitive Recursive Relations.- 3 Ordinals.- 3.1 Heuristic.- 3.2 Some Basic Facts on Ordinals.- 3.3 Fundamentals of Ordinal Arithmetic.- 3.3.1 A Notation System for the Ordinals below epsilon nought.- 3.4 The Veblen Hierarchy.- 3.4.1 Preliminaries.- 3.4.2 The Veblen Hierarchy.- 3.4.3 A Notation System for the Ordinals below Gamma nought.- 4 Pure Logic.- 4.1 Heiristics.- 4.2 First and Second Order Logic.- 4.3 The Tait calculus.- 4.4 Trees and the Completeness Theorem.- 4.5 Gentzens Hauptsatz for Pure First Order Logic.- 4.6 Second Order Logic.- 5 Truth Complexities for Pi 1-1-Sentences.- 5.1 The language of Arithmetic.- 5.2 The Tait language for Second Order Arithmetic.- 5.3 Truth Complexities for Arithmetical Sentences.- 5.4 Truth Complexities for Pi 1-1-Sentences.- 6 Inductive Definitions.- 6.1 Motivation.- 6.2 Inductive Definitions as Monotone Operators.- 6.3 The Stages of an Inductive Definition.- 6.4 Arithmetically Definable Inductive Definitions.- 6.5 Inductive Definitions, Well-Orderings and Well-Founded Trees.- 6.6 Inductive Definitions and Truth Complexities.- 6.7 The Pi-1-1- Ordinal of a Theory.- 7 The Ordinal Analysis for Pean Arithmetic.- 7.1 The Theory PA.- 7.2 The Theory NT.- 7.3 The Upper Bound.- 7.4 The Lower Bound.- 7.5 The Use of Gentzen's Consistency Proof for Hilbert's Programme.- 7.5.1 On the Consistency of Formal and Semi-Formal Systems.- 7.5.2 The Consistency of NT.- 7.5.3 Kreisel's Counterexample.- 7.5.4 Gentzen's Consistency Proof in the Light of Hilbert's Programme.- 8 Autonomous Ordinals and the Limits of Predicativity.- 8.1 The Language L-kappa.- 8.2 Semantics for L-kappa.- 8.3 Autonomous Ordinals.- 8.4 The Upper Bound for Autonomous Ordinals.- 8.5 The Lower Bound for Autonomous Ordinals.- 9 Ordinal Analysis of the Theory for Inductive Definitions.- 9.1 The Theory ID1.- 9.2 The Language L infinity (NT).- 9.3 The Semi-FormalSystem for L infinity (NT).- 9.3.1 Semantical Cut-Elimination.- 9.3.2 Operator Controlled Derivations.- 9.4 The Collapsing Theorem for ID1.- 9.5 The Upper Bound.- 9.6 The Lower Bound.- 9.6.1 Coding Ordinals in L(NT).- 9.6.2 The Well-Ordering Proof.- 9.7 Alternative Interpretations for Omega.- 10 Provably Recursive Functions of NT.- 10.1 Provably Recursive Functions of a Theory.- 10.2 Operator Controlled Derivations.- 10.3 Iterating Operators.- 10.4 Cut Elimination for Operator Controlled Derivations.- 10.5 The Embedding of NT.- 10.6 Discussion.- 11 Ordinal Analysis for Kripke Platek Set Theory with infinity.- 11.1 Naive Set Theory.- 11.2 The Language of Set Theory.- 11.3 Constructible Sets.- 11.4 Kripke Platek Set Theory.- 11.5 ID1 as a Subtheory of Kp-omega.- 11.6 Variations of KP-omega and Axiom beta.- 11.7 The Sigma Ordinal of KP-omega.- 11.8 The Theory of Pi-2 Reflection.- 11.9 An Infinite Verification Calculus for the Constructible Hierarchy.- 11.10 A Semi-Formal System for Ramified Set Theory.- 11.11 The Collapsing Theorem for Ramified Set Theory.- 11.12 Ordinal Analysis for Kripke Platek Set Theory.- 12 Predicativity Revisited.- 12.1 Admissible Extensions.- 12.2 M-Logic.- 12.3 Extending Semi-Formal Systems.- 12.4 Asymmetric Interpretations.- 12.5 Reduction of T+ to T.- 12.6 The Theories KP n and KP 0-n.- 12.7 The Theories KPl 0 and KP i 0.- 13 Non-Monotone Inductive Definitions.- 13.1 Non-Monotone Inductive Definitions.- 13.2 Prewellorderings.- 13.3 The Theory for Pi 0-1 definable Fixed-Points.- 13.4 ID1 as a Sub-Theory of the Theory for Pi 0-1 definable Fixed-Points.- 13.5 The Upper Bound for the Proof theoretical Ordinal of Pi 0-1-FXP.- 14 Epilogue.

O autorze

Wolfram Pohlers (born 1943) is Full Professor and Director of the Institute for Mathematical Logic and Foundational Resarch at the Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität in Münster, Germany. He received his scientific training at the University of Munich where he worked as an Associate Professor from 1980 to 1985. From 1989 to 1990 he was a visiting scholar at the MSRI in Berkley and in 2005 he taught at the Ohio State University in Columbus.

Blurb

This book verifies with compelling evidence the author’s intent to "write a book on proof theory that needs no previous knowledge of proof theory". Avoiding the cryptic terminology of proof theory as far as possible, the book starts at an elementary level and displays the connections between infinitary proof theory and generalized recursion theory, especially the theory of inductive definitions. As a "warm up" Gentzen's classical analysis of pure number theory is presented in a more modern terminology, followed by an explanation and proof of the famous result of Feferman and Schütte on the limits of predicativity. The author also provides an introduction to ordinal arithmetic, introduces the Veblen hierarchy and employs these functions to design an ordinal notation system for the ordinals below Epsilon 0 and Gamma 0, while emphasizing the first step into impredicativity, that is, the first step beyond Gamma 0. This is first done by an analysis of the theory of non-iterated inductive definitions using Buchholz’s improvement of local predicativity, followed by Weiermann's observation that Buchholz’s method can also be used for predicative theories to characterize their provably recursive functions. A second example presents an ordinal analysis of the theory of $/Pi_2$ reflection, a subsystem of set theory that is proof-theoretically equivalent to Kripke-Platek set.

The book is pitched at undergraduate/graduate level, and thus addressed to students of mathematical logic interested in the basics of proof theory. It can be used for introductory as well as more advanced courses in proof theory.

An earlier version of this book was published in 1989 as volume 1407 of the "Lecture Notes in Mathematics" (ISBN 978-3-540-51842-6).