Data Enclaves

ISBN-13: 9783031464010 / Angielski / Twarda / 2023

Kean Birch

Opis

This book focuses on our increasing dependence upon Big Tech to live, manage, and enjoy our lives. The author examines how we freely exchange our personal data for access to online platforms, services, and devices without proper consideration of the implications of this trade. Our personal data is the defining resource of the emerging digital economy, and it is increasingly concentrated in a few data enclaves controlled by Big Tech firms, cementing an increasingly parasitic form of technoscientific innovation. Big Tech controls access to these data, dictates the terms of our use of their services and products, and controls the future development of key technologies like artificial intelligence. The contention of this book is that we need to rethink our political and policy approach to data governance and to do so requires unpacking the peculiarities of personal data and how personal data are transformed into a valuable asset. 

Spis treści

Chapter 1: Introduction: What We All Need to Know About Our Personal Data

 

As a result of their waxing influence, Big Tech firms have come under the public and political spotlight over the past few years, especially because of growing concerns about their social and market power. The 2018 Cambridge Analytica scandal, in particular, revealed that Big Tech firms like Facebook are sharing our personal data with little regard for our consent. The Financial Times commentator Rana Faroohar defines the resulting backlash against Big Tech since 2018 as the ‘techlash’, while the business professor Shoshana Zuboff’s 2019 book The Age of Surveillance Capitalism has come to define the way many people think about Big Tech firms today. This chapter provides an introduction to the key issues with the current, market-based form of personal data governance that has led to these scandals and widening problems with the control Big Tech has over all aspects of our lives, from our purchasing habits to our political discourse. It will outline the ways that our personal data is being collected, user, and governed, contrasting the differences between the North American and European contexts.

 

Chapter 2: What is Big Tech?

 

Generally, Big Tech can be characterized as the five largest technology firms in the world, usually defined by their market capitalization – the total value of their shares. Currently, Big Tech includes Apple, Amazon, Microsoft, Alphabet/Google, and Facebook; sometimes they get called GAFAM or FAANG – an acronym representing the first letter of these five firms. Whatever name we use, it’s become increasingly evident over the last few years that Big Tech has an outsized and unhealthy influence over our lives. This chapter will outline the rise of and backlash against Big Tech over the last two decades. It will provide the political-economic context for the book by outlining the expansion of personal data collection, use, and exploitation by Big Tech firms and their conversion of personal data into a private asset that is legible and measurable as a valuable resource, while problematizing the idea that it is the characteristics of the digital technologies themselves that underpins Big Tech’s increasing influence.

 

Chapter 3: The Rise of Data Rentiership

 

Thinking of the transformation of personal data into a private asset helps us to understand the emerging forms of data governance pursued by Big Tech. These firms turn our personal data into a private asset in order to extract value from it. This assetization of personal data depends on a range of activities, but firms like Apple, Amazon, Microsoft, Google, and Facebook can capture the most value by creating data monopolies from the network effects and monopolistic strategies enabled by their extension of digital ecosystems comprising platforms, devices, contractual arrangements, users, developers, etc. As a result, digital technologies have ended up configured and shaped by the search for ways to create, extend, and reinforce control over data, creating various forms of rentiership ranging from the buying up of competitors through limiting regulations and competition by lobbying governments to creating self-preferential on their platforms. Data rentiership entails creating a series of data enclaves designed to limit access to personal and user data and to get us to spend as much of our time as creating more data by using our smartphones, computers, or social media. As a result, Big Tech has created a series of walled data gardens that lock-in users, competitors, and policymakers to particular visions of future innovation in which the role of Big Tech seems necessary and inevitable.

 

Chapter 4: Emerging Data Enclaves

 

As the collection of our personal data has increased, Big Tech firms have become more dependent on data rentiership as a way to make money. Today, a few Big Tech firms have amassed so much of our personal data that many policymakers, businesspeople, academics, activists, journalists, and others fear these data enclaves will limit the emergence of new digital technology startups to compete with these incumbent firms. This chapter will consider how Big Tech’s data enclaves give these firms a problematic first-mover advantage when it comes to developing new digital technologies, especially algorithmic systems and artificial intelligence that need large datasets to ‘train’ them. This stifling of innovation is just one fear, however, as there are many other concerns about the implications of these data enclaves to our privacy or democracy. The chapter will also outline some of the wider social implications of these data enclaves on artificial intelligence and algorithmic systems in the entrenchment of social prejudices or economic discrimination.

 

Chapter 5: Monopoly, Competition, and Emergent Data

 

Contemporary capitalism is increasingly driven by the pursuit of data enclaves. This transformation is ongoing and has created a tension between those who think that our current laws are able to regulate data-driven economies and those who think that we need to rethink our market rules, especially when it comes to dealing with monopoly and market competition. This chapter will outline the fundamental disruption of contemporary, technoscientific capitalism caused by data enclaves, which makes it such a distinct techno-economic system and, therefore, one that needs a range of new policies and regulatory mechanisms to ensure that the economy does not end up monopolized by a few Big Tech firms. The chapter will examine changes the emergent properties of personal data as a digital asset form; that is, the properties of personal data as an aggregated, political-economic object. These properties entail a totally different approach to competition policy and law. Currently different countries are pursuing different approaches to monopoly and competition policy in response to the emerging problems that data enclaves engender, but these different policymakers do not always understand the implications of ‘emergent’ data to the functioning of markets.

 

Chapter 6: A New Policy Agenda for Data Governance

 

Rather than a normal conclusion, the book will end by outlining a new policy agenda for data governance in light of the preceding chapters. This new policy agenda focuses specifically on the importance of going beyond privacy and market-based approaches to the governance of personal data. As post hoc and distinct governance approaches, privacy and competition policies are limited in the ways that they can build new social demands into the collection and use of our personal data. Rather, this chapter will discuss how personal data governance and competition policy needs to be built on an aggregate and emergent perspective of personal data – for example, the collection and use of my personal data impacts you, whether you like it or not, and vice versa – and develop ‘proactionary’ approaches to data governance and competition that: (1) establishes the goals of digital innovation before Big Tech develops new products and services; (2) restricts the capacity of Big Tech to experiment on us with new technologies; and (3) develops a new understanding of contract and contract law with ‘modular’ contractual articles/principles that users can pick and choose from without losing access to the services or products they need to live their lives.

O autorze

Kean Birch is Director of the Institute for Technoscience & Society and Professor in the Science & Technology Studies Graduate Program at York University, Canada. He has been a Visiting Scholar at Copenhagen Business School and the Munich Center for Technology & Society, Technical University Munich. He is especially interested in understanding how different things are transformed into assets and what this means for our increasingly technoscientific economies and societies.

Blurb

This book focuses on our increasing dependence upon Big Tech to live, manage, and enjoy our lives. The author examines how we freely exchange our personal data for access to online platforms, services, and devices without proper consideration of the implications of this trade. Our personal data is the defining resource of the emerging digital economy, and it is increasingly concentrated in a few data enclaves controlled by Big Tech firms, cementing an increasingly parasitic form of technoscientific innovation. Big Tech controls access to these data, dictates the terms of our use of their services and products, and controls the future development of key technologies like artificial intelligence. The contention of this book is that we need to rethink our political and policy approach to data governance and to do so requires unpacking the peculiarities of personal data and how personal data are transformed into a valuable asset.

 

Kean Birch is Director of the Institute for Technoscience & Society and Professor in the Science & Technology Studies Graduate Program at York University, Canada. He has been a Visiting Scholar at Copenhagen Business School and the Munich Center for Technology & Society, Technical University Munich. He is especially interested in understanding how different things are transformed into assets and what this means for our increasingly technoscientific economies and societies.